Trust your doctor, not Wikipedia, say scientists

[G1njas]

Trust your doctor, not Wikipedia, say scientists

Wikipedia, the online encyclopaedia, contains errors in nine out of 10 of its health entries, and should be treated with caution, a study has said.

 

Scientists in the US compared entries about conditions such as heart disease, lung cancer, depression and diabetes with peer-reviewed medical research.

 

They said most articles in Wikipedia contained "many errors".

 

Wikimedia UK, its British arm, said it was "crucial" that people with health concerns spoke to their GP first.

From a public health standpoint, patients should not use [Wikipedia] as a primary resource because those articles do not go through the same peer-review process as medical journals”

 

Dr Robert Hasty Wallace School of Osteopathic Medicine, North Carolina

Open-access 'concerns'

 

The online encyclopaedia is a charity, and has 30 million articles in 285 languages.

 

It can be edited by anybody, but many volunteers from the medical profession check the pages for inaccuracies, said Wikimedia UK.

 

The open-access nature has "raised concern" among doctors about its reliability, as it is the sixth most popular site on the internet, the US authors of the research, published in the Journal of the American Osteopathic Association, said.

 

Up to 70% of physicians and medical students use the tool, they say.

 

The 10 researchers across America looked at online articles for 10 of the "most costly" conditions in the US, including osteoarthritis, back problems and asthma.

 

They printed off the articles on 25 April 2012 to analyse, and discovered that 90% of the entries made statements that contradicted latest medical research.

Continue reading the main story

“Start Quote

 

Wikipedia, like any encyclopaedia, should not take the place of a qualified medical practitioner”

 

Stevie Benton Wikimedia UK

 

Lead author Dr Robert Hasty, of the Wallace School of Osteopathic Medicine in North Carolina, said: "While Wikipedia is a convenient tool for conducting research, from a public health standpoint patients should not use it as a primary resource because those articles do not go through the same peer-review process as medical journals."

 

Dr Hasty added the "best resource" for people worried about their health was their doctor.

Contact GP 'first'

Stevie Benton, at Wikimedia UK, said there were a "number of initiatives" in place to help improve the articles, "especially in relation to health and medicine".

 

He said the charity had a project to bring together volunteer Wikipedia editors with a medical knowledge to identify articles that need improvement, find credible sources and make entries more "accurate and more readable".

 

Mr Benton said Wikipedia was also working with Cancer Research UK to review cancer-related articles by clinical researchers and writers to keep them accurate and up-to-date.

 

But he added: "However, it is crucial that anybody with concerns over their health contacts their GP as a first point of call. Wikipedia, like any encyclopaedia, should not take the place of a qualified medical practitioner."

 

Wikipedia also expressed concern at the small sample size used in the research, as it may not be representative.

 

The study did not account for Wikipedia leaving out important information.

Fonte: BBC News

Editado 27 Maio 2014 por G1njas

[Sahar]

Isso quer dizer que esta dor de cabeça que me tem dado de vez em quando NÃO é SIDA?

[Oblivion]

Isso quer dizer que esta dor de cabeça que me tem dado de vez em quando NÃO é SIDA?

 

Não, é gravidez.

[M. Porter]

[Enzo Dios Perez]

Ohhh então isso não me abrange, eu costumo pesquisar no yahoo answers.

[Gustavo_Kei]

eu costumo escrever os meus sintomas no paint, envio para 10 mails aleatórios, e depois carrego na página aleatória da wikipédia até paracer uma doença.

Médicos são tão overrated

[Varela]

Supostamente já tive cancro do pulmão, pele e fígado.

[Red Prince]

Já fiz 2 ou 3 trabalhos por lá, daqueles mais a despachar

[Enzo Dios Perez]

Eu já fiz um copy/paste na íntegra, tirei 14 e fiquei muito feliz.

[Ricardo Gouveia]

Que diferença vai fazer? Já tenho quase todos os tipos de cancro.

[Chandler]

Continuem, pode ser que alguém ainda consiga ter piada.

[Lip McBoatface]

Tá certo, ancião mor das piadas secas,

[Chandler]

É sempre giro seres tu a dizer isso, não sei se pela postura parecida se por em trinta acertares uma. :-k

[Lip McBoatface]

Elá, ficaste mesmo picadinho :lol:

[Sahar]

Continuem, pode ser que alguém ainda consiga ter piada.

reputei, muito bom

[Chucky-PT]

[Che]

tenho cancro nos ovários

[lastdance]

Cancro na piada é que ninguém tem.

[Kanye]

Cancro na piada é que toda a gente tem.

fixed

[lastdance]

fixed

para isso tinham de ter piada